Searching for the perfect car seat that ticks all the boxes? Look no further than the Safety 1st Go And Grow And Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1.
The Safety 1st option offers a more "compact" design, lighter weight, and a luxurious level of comfort with its plush seat pads. Plus, it proudly bears the "Made in the USA" label, ensuring quality craftsmanship.
But wait, have you considered the Graco Extend2fit? It takes car seat innovation to new heights with a higher rear-facing weight limit, a booster seat that grows with your child, and a 4-position leg extension panel for added comfort. Not to mention, its extensive safety tests and reinforced frame provide ultimate peace of mind.
With features like these, can the Safety 1st Go And Grow And Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1 truly measure up?
Read on.
Safety 1st Go And Grow | Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1 | |
Rear-Facing Weight: | 5 to 40 lbs | 4 to 50 pounds |
Rear-Facing Height Limit: | 19 to 40 inches | the head must be at least 1-inch below the headrest adjustment handle |
Forward-Facing Weight: | 22 to 65 pounds | |
Forward-Facing Height Limit: | 29 to 49 inches | Up to 49 inches |
High Back Booster Weight: | 40 to 100 pounds | |
High Back Booster Height Limit: | 43 to 52 inches | 43 to 57 inches |
The Safety 1st Go And Grow has a slightly lower rear-facing weight limit, while the Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1 has a higher range for rear-facing weight.
In terms of rear-facing height, the Safety 1st Go And Grow provides a specific range, whereas the Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1 requires the child's head to be at least 1 inch below the headrest adjustment handle.
For forward-facing, both car seats have the same weight and height limits.
Regarding high back booster mode, both seats specify a weight limit of 40 to 100 pounds, but the height limit of Safety 1st is lower at 43 to 52 inches only compared to the Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1’s 57 inches limit.
Safety 1st Go And Grow | Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1 | |
Width | 19 inches | |
Height | 24 inches | 24.5 inches |
Depth/Length | 23.75 inches | 20.75 inches |
We can see that both the Safety 1st Go And Grow and Graco Extend2fit has a specified width of 19 inches.
In terms of height, the Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1 is slightly taller at 24.5 inches compared to the Safety 1st Go And Grow, which is 24 inches in height.
For depth/length, the Safety 1st Go And Grow is 23.75 inches, while the Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1 is 20.75 inches. However, it's important to note that when using the anti-rebound bar, the Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1 car seat's total depth increases to 26.75 inches.
The Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1 also has the additional feature of a 4-position adjustable extension panel, which can provide up to 5 inches of additional legroom for a more extended rear-facing position. While this is beneficial for comfort, it may also require more space in the car and could potentially be challenging to fit in smaller cars.
Safety 1st Go And Grow | Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1 | |
Do I need to use a pool noodle/rolled towel? | Yes, allowed according to manual | No |
Easy To Install Rear-Facing | Relatively | Yes |
Easy To Install Forward-Facing? | Relatively | Yes |
Easy To Uninstall? | Yes | |
The Graco Extend2fit 3in1 car seat offers notable advantages in terms of installation. One major benefit is that it eliminates the need for additional items like pool noodles or rolled towels during installation. Also, the process of installing the car seat both in rear-facing and forward-facing positions is straightforward and hassle-free.
One of the key features that enhances the installation ease of the Graco Extend2fit 3in1 car seat is the InRight™ LATCH system it utilizes. This system simplifies the installation process, making it more user-friendly and efficient. On the other hand, the Safety 1st Go And Grow car seat, specifically with the J-hook type of LATCH, presents some challenges when it comes to installation convenience.
In terms of uninstallation, both the Graco Extend2fit 3in1 and Safety 1st Go And Grow car seats are reported to be easy to uninstall. This means that removing either of these car seats from your vehicle is a straightforward process, adding to the overall convenience and user-friendliness of the products.
Safety 1st Go And Grow | Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1 | |
Country Of Origin: | USA | China |
Steel-Reinforced Frame: | No | Yes |
Five-Point Harness? | Yes | |
Side Impact Tested: | Yes | |
Approved For Airplane Use: | Yes | |
Easy To Buckle And Unbuckle? | Yes | |
The Safety 1st Go And Grow is manufactured in the USA, while the Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1 is made in China.
The Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1 has a steel-reinforced frame for added strength and durability, unlike the Safety 1st Go And Grow.
Both car seats have a reliable five-point harness system for secure restraint.
They have undergone thorough side impact testing to ensure effective occupant retention.
Both are approved for airplane use.
The Safety 1st Go And Grow and the Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1 are designed to be user-friendly, but the Safety 1st Grow and Go's straps are flimsy and tend to get twisted. The strap covers may also not stay in place.
The Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1 has additional safety features, including Graco® ProtectPlus Engineered™ technology, which provides protection in various types of crashes. It exceeds the criteria for frontal crash testing and has undergone rear-impact and rollover testing. It also includes an Anti-Rebound Bar for extra rear-facing safety and has been tested for structural integrity in extreme temperatures.
Overall, the Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1 offers enhanced protection for your child.
Good Convertible Car Seats Of 2023
Consider narrowing down your options by focusing on those made with EPP or EPS foam for impact management. Both materials meet government safety regulations, but EPP foam is more elastic and less brittle than EPS foam, making it better at withstanding multiple impacts and regaining its shape.
Keep in mind that any seat involved in an accident should be replaced, regardless of the foam type.
Good Convertible Car Seats With EPP Foam:
Good Convertible Car Seats With EPS Foam:
Safety 1st Go And Grow | Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1 | |
Is The Material Breathable? | Yes | |
Seat Weight: | 15.4 pounds | 20.61 pounds |
Machine Washable Cover? | Yes | |
Roomy? | Yes | |
No-Rethread Harness? | Yes | |
Easy To Remove Cover? | Yes | Yes (Rapid Remove) |
Expiration | 10 Years | |
Comes With A Cup Holder? | Yes, 2 | |
Shoulder Harness Has Pads? | Yes | |
Recline Positions | 3 | 6 |
Both car seats are made of breathable materials, ensuring comfort for the child even during long rides. They also have machine-washable covers that make it convenient to clean up spills or messes.
In terms of weight, the Safety 1st Go And Grow is lighter, weighing 15.4 pounds, while the Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1 weighs 20.61 pounds. The lighter weight of the Safety 1st seat can be advantageous for portability.
Both car seats are described as roomy, providing ample space for the child to sit comfortably.
They also feature a no-rethread harness, allowing for easy adjustment of the straps without the need to rethread them manually. This feature adds convenience for parents as their child grows.
Additionally, both car seats have covers that are easy to remove, simplifying the process of cleaning or maintenance.
They also have an expiration period of 10 years, ensuring long-term usability and safety.
Both seats come with two cup holders, however, there have been reports of the cup holders on the Graco seat detaching easily.
The Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1 offers six recline positions, providing more flexibility and options for adjusting the seat to accommodate the child's needs. On the other hand, the Safety 1st Go And Grow has three recline positions.
The Safety 1st Go And Grow is praised for its good head cushions, which play an essential role in providing comfort.
There is an approximately USD130 price difference between the Safety 1st Go And Grow and the Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1. The Safety 1st is cheaper.
With Safety 1st, you get
- A more “compact” seat
- A seat made in the USA
- A lighter seat
- A super comfortable seat because of the seat pads
With the Graco Extend2fit, you get
- A higher rear-facing weight limit
- A higher booster height limit
- A 4-position leg extension panel
- No need for a pool noodle or rolled towel for installation
- An InRight LATCH system for easier LATCH installation
- A more straight-forward forward-facing installation
- A steel-reinforced frame
- An Anti-Rebound bar
- A seat that has undergone more safety tests
- A Rapid Remove seat cover
- More recline positions
Do You Need More Help To Decide Between
The Safety 1st Go And Grow And Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1?
What do you think?
I’d love to know your thoughts in the comments section below!
Cheers!
Pitin
Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1 With Anti Rebound Bar Vs
*affiliate links