Parents who are in search of a car seat that offers both safety and comfort for their child may find themselves torn between two excellent options: the Chicco Onefit ClearTex or the Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1. Both car seats have a lot to offer, but which one is the better choice? It's a tough call, but one thing is for sure: both of these car seats are worthy contenders.
Chicco Onefit ClearTex | Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1 | |
Rear-Facing Weight: | 5 to 40 pounds | 4 to 50 pounds |
Rear-Facing Height Limit: | Up to 43 inches | The head must be at least 1inch below the handle |
Forward-Facing Weight: | 22 to 65 pounds | |
Forward-Facing Height Limit: | Up to 54 inches | Up to 49 inches |
High Back Booster Weight: | 40 to 100 pounds | |
High Back Booster Height Limit: | Up to 57 inches | 43 to 57 inches |
The Chicco Onefit ClearTex and Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1 can be both used for rear-facing, forward-facing, and high-back booster modes.
The Extend2fit has a higher weight limit for the rear-facing position. It also has a unique feature of an adjustable extension panel for additional legroom in the rear-facing position.
In the forward-facing mode, both seats have the same weight limit but the Chicco Onefit has a higher height limit.
Both seats have the same weight limit and similar height limit for the high-back booster mode.
Chicco Onefit ClearTex | Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1 | |
Width | 19 inches | |
Height | 27 inches | 24.5 inches |
Depth/Length | 21.5 inches | 20.75 inches |
The Chicco Onefit ClearTex and Graco Extend2fit 3-in-1 have the same width, but the Chicco can be made narrower by folding the cupholder. This feature makes it a better option for parents with smaller cars or those who need to fit multiple car seats.
The Graco's adjustable extension panel provides more legroom for rear-facing positions, which is beneficial but may pose a challenge for smaller vehicles.
In terms of depth/length, the Graco has a relatively compact size of 20.75 inches. However, when the anti-rebound bar is used, the car seat's total depth increases to 26.75 inches, which requires more space in the car.
Chicco Onefit ClearTex | Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1 | |
Do I need to use a pool noodle/rolled towel? | No | |
Easy To Install Rear-Facing | Yes | |
Easy To Install Forward-Facing? | Yes | |
Easy To Uninstall? | Yes | |
The Chicco Onefit ClearTex and Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1 are both easy to install and uninstall without the need for a pool noodle or rolled towel.
The Chicco Onefit ClearTex has premium LATCH connectors, a SuperCinch® force-multiplying tightener, bubble levels, and a LockSure® steel reinforced seatbelt lock-off system.
The Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1 uses the InRight™ LATCH system but does not come with a seatbelt lock-off feature.
Note that the Graco Extend2fit extends further out onto the vehicle seat, and care must be taken to ensure it does not hang over the edge.
Chicco Onefit ClearTex | Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1 | |
Country Of Origin: | China | |
Steel-Reinforced Frame: | Yes | |
Five-Point Harness? | Yes | |
Side Impact Tested: | Yes | |
Approved For Airplane Use: | Yes | |
Easy To Buckle And Unbuckle? | Yes | |
Both the Chicco Onefit ClearTex and the Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1 are car seats manufactured in China with similar basic safety features, such as a steel-reinforced frame and a five-point harness.
However, the Chicco Onefit ClearTex has additional safety features to provide an extra layer of protection to the child. One such feature is the DuoGuard® two-layer protection system, which minimizes the risk of injury in the event of a crash.
The Onefit car seat also has an EPS energy-absorbing foam that surrounds the head and torso of the child, reducing the impact of a collision on their body. To ensure that it can provide effective protection in the event of a side-impact collision, the Chicco OneFit ClearTex has undergone rigorous testing specifically designed to simulate such collisions.
On the other hand, the Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1 car seat has a more extensive range of safety testing and additional safety features. It has Graco® ProtectPlus Engineered™, which combines the most rigorous crash tests to protect the child in frontal, side, rear, and rollover crashes.
In addition to the EPS energy-absorbing foam that helps manage the impact of a collision, the Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1 is also equipped with an anti-rebound bar that limits rotation of the seat and child in rear-facing mode, providing an extra layer of safety in case of an impact.
The Graco Extend2fit has also been tested for frontal crashes based on the US FMVSS 213, rear impacts based on the European Rear-Impact Crash Pulse, and rollover testing based on the European rollover testing procedure. Additionally, the car seat has been tested for structural integrity in extreme hot and cold temperatures.
In conclusion, both car seats have excellent safety features, but the Graco Extend2fit seat has a wider range of safety testing and additional features such as the anti-rebound bar, which provides an extra layer of protection in rear-facing mode.
Good Convertible Car Seats Of 2023
Consider narrowing down your options by focusing on those made with EPP or EPS foam for impact management. Both materials meet government safety regulations, but EPP foam is more elastic and less brittle than EPS foam, making it better at withstanding multiple impacts and regaining its shape.
Keep in mind that any seat involved in an accident should be replaced, regardless of the foam type.
Good Convertible Car Seats With EPP Foam:
Good Convertible Car Seats With EPS Foam:
Chicco Onefit ClearTex | Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1 | |
Is The Material Breathable? | Yes | |
Seat Weight: | 25 pounds | 20.61 pounds |
Machine Washable Cover? | Yes | |
Roomy? | Yes | |
No-Rethread Harness? | Yes | |
Easy To Remove Cover? | Yes | Yes (Rapid Remove) |
Expiration | 10 Years | |
Comes With A Cup Holder? | Yes, 2 | |
Shoulder Harness Has Pads? | Yes | |
Headrest Positions | 10 | |
Recline Positions | 9 | 6 |
The Chicco Onefit ClearTex and Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1 car seats share several features, including breathability, roominess, machine washable covers, and no-rethread harnesses with shoulder pads. They also have the same number of headrest positions.
The Onefit is slightly heavier, weighing 25 pounds, while the Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1 is lighter, weighing 20.61 pounds.
However, the Extend2fit model offers a Rapid Remove cover feature, which allows for easier and quicker cleaning compared to traditional covers.
Both car seats have a 10-year expiration and two cup holders, but the Onefit's cup holder is foldable for space-saving purposes.
In terms of adjustability, the Onefit offers more recline positions, with 9 compared to the Graco's 6.
There is an approximately USD10 price difference between the Chicco Onefit ClearTex and Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1. The Onefit ClearTex is more expensive.
With the Chicco Onefit ClearTex, you get
- A higher forward-facing height limit
- A more compact seat due to the foldable cupholders as well as the absence of an extendable foot panel and an anti-rebound bar
- Has a steel-reinforced seatbelt lock-off system for easier seatbelt installation
- Has more reclining positions
With the Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1, you get
- A higher rear-facing weight limit
- An extendable foot panel for a more comfortable ride
- An Anti-Rebound bar for extra safety
- A seat that has undergone more safety tests
- A lighter seat
- A Rapid Remove cover
Do You Need More Help To Decide Between
The Chicco Onefit ClearTex or Graco Extend2fit 3 in 1?
What do you think?
I’d love to know your thoughts in the comments section below!
Cheers!
Pitin
*affiliate links