The Cosco Scenera Next and Evenflo Tribute LX are among the affordable car seats parents can find in the market. While they are both very basic car seats with no frills, they can surely do their job either as a secondary car seat or travel car seat. While parents may afford both seats, it will always be practical to choose one that is better than the other and I think this better car seat is the Cosco Scenera Next. Be sure to read more below, to discover what made me (and what could also make you) ultimately come up with this conclusion.

 

Cosco Scenera Next Convertible Car Seat with Cup Holder (Moon Mist Grey)
(* = affiliate link / image source: Amazon partner program)

Cosco Scenera Next*

Vs

Evenflo Tribute LX*

(* = affiliate link / image source: Amazon partner program)

 

Ideal Use


 

Cosco Scenera Next Evenflo Tribute LX
Rear-Facing Weight: 5 to 40 pounds
Rear-Facing Height Limit: 19 to 40 inches 19 to 37 inches
Forward-Facing Weight: 22 to 40 pounds
Forward-Facing Height Limit: 29 to 43 inches 28 to 40 inches

 

  • Rear-Facing

While both child restraints are marketed to be able to sit a 5-pound baby, parents might not feel comfortable with how the harness of each car seat would fit such a child and how each car seat lacks in providing a more recline position for younger children. Either child restraint would only start providing a snug fit on infants at least 7 pounds in weight.

Maximum height is what differentiates Cosco Scenera Next from Evenflo Tribute LX and vice versa in terms of rear-facing mode.  Scenera Next can accommodate a child up to 40 inches in height while Tribute LX can only have room in rear-facing for a child 37 inches in height. The extra 3 inches would be of big use for children who are taller than most.

  • Forward-Facing

Once again, Scenera Next has a higher maximum height limit than Tribute LX.

Both seats might not be of satisfactory use in forward-facing considering they can accommodate only up to 40 pounds while other convertible car seats can hold a child up to 65 pounds. Either car seat could possibly be used forward-facing for children 2-3 years old, as long as they meet the shoulder strap requirement (shoulder strap position must be above the shoulders).

 

Good All-In-One Car Seats


 

Will It Fit In My Car?


 

Cosco Scenera Next Evenflo Tribute LX
Width 17 inches 18.5 inches
Height 23.5 inches 25.5 inches
Depth/Length 22 inches

 

  • Space-Saving

To be able to maximize a row of seats inside a vehicle will be appreciated by almost all parents. Regardless of the vehicle size and/or family size, the obvious choice for a space saving car seat is the Cosco Scenera Next since it is slimmer and narrower than Evenflo Tribute LX. At 17 inches in width, it could readily fit 3-across in a midsize SUV or a minivan, just like other more expensive products like Diono Radian 3RXT and/or Clek Foonf and Fllo.

Still, there are situations where parents may experiment on various combinations of configurations (rear-facing or forward-facing) for the Tribute LX and other narrow car seats to see if they can be installed side by side on a row of vehicle seats.

  • Fit In Vehicles

If you would read reviews on Cosco Scenera Next, you would be able to learn that many parents bought this product mainly for their air travels. Many parents attest that the Scenera Next fit perfectly on Airplane seats like JetBlue, Southwest and Etihad flights. It also fits well on the seat of a Boeing 737 airplane. One parent recommends using travel strollers for lugging the Scenera Next around. In one of the reviews, another parent also commented that this lightweight car seat would fit under some larger strollers.

Many parent reviewers also claimed that Tribute LX is light enough to carry as a travel car seat, but the name of the airlines was not mentioned. One reviewer explained she was able to install 2 Tribute LX seats in a Toyota Corolla. Another parent who drives a Nissan Tiida hatchback said that Tribute LX was mounted on its center back seat. 

 

Good Two Way Car Seats


 

Installation


 

  Cosco Scenera Next Evenflo Tribute LX
Do I need to use a pool noodle/rolled towel? Yes, indicated in the manual
Easy To Install Rear-Facing? Yes
Easy To Install Forward-Facing? Yes
Easy To Uninstall? Yes
Recline Position Fixed
Lower Anchor Weight Limit None in effect

 

  • Pool Noodle/Rolled Towel

More posh and costly car seats with multiple recline positions, according to reviews, still require the use of pool noodles and rolled towels on some vehicles. Thus, it is no wonder if parents who decide to purchase either of these car seats will also find it is necessary to put such aftermarket products to prop it up to an appropriate recline. Take note, however, that the manual of the Tribute LX only mentions rolled towels and/or blankets and not cut-to-size pool noodles. 

  • Recline

Scenera Next has a fixed recline. You just park the vehicle on level ground and refer to the line at the side of the seat to determine if the car seat is properly leveled.  For children who still could sit unassisted, the grommets under the shell should touch the vehicle seat so that Scenera Next may be installed at a more upright position.  

With Tribute LX, there is an adjustment foot parents must use accordingly to alter the seat angle for correct installation. There is also an arrow line for checking if the car seat is leveled to the ground.

  • Installation

Although both car seats are bare bones basic, parents actually find them rather easy to install. They may not be equipped with some fancy connectors or installation features, but they can be installed without encountering any serious issues that cannot be solved by watching some helpful videos.  

  • Lower Anchor Weight Limit

Each of these 2 child passenger safety seats are substantially lightweight compared to other convertible car seats in the market. They each have a maximum weight limit of 40 pounds and even if their less than 10 pounds weight is added, the usual 65 pounds maximum lower anchor weight limit will not be exceeded. Thus, there is no lower anchor weight limit in effect for these 2 child restraints. For other convertible car seats, parents are reminded to pay attention to their growing child’s weight as they might need to switch the installation mode from LATCH to seatbelt once the child’s weight reaches the limit so as not to compromise safety. With Scenera Next and/or Tribute LX, this step of switching the installation mode will not be necessary.

 

Cosco Scenera Next Convertible Car Seat with Cup Holder (Moon Mist Grey)
By
Price: --
(As of: 2021/10/07 3:56 am - Details
×
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on https://www.amazon.com/ at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
)
1 new from $93.960 used
(* = affiliate link / image source: Amazon partner program)

 

Safety


 

Cosco Scenera Next Evenflo Tribute LX
Country Of Origin: USA
Steel Frame: No
Five-Point Harness? Yes
Side Impact Tested: Yes
Approved For Airplane Use: Yes
Easy To Buckle And Unbuckle? Yes

 

  • Safety Testimonials

The entries in the safety table above would not be very helpful in picking out which is the better car seat between the 2. Thus, parents might be left with reading available testimonials from parents who have used the products and have 1st hand experience on how the seats performed during real life accidents on the road.

For Cosco Scenera Next, you may this article . It recounted a road accident that involved a totally wrecked car. There were 2 infant passengers involved, but neither baby was injured badly. The model and brand of the car seats used was not mentioned, but babycenter.com members shared that the car seats were Cosco Scenera Next, based on the photos on the article.

For Evenflo Tribute LX, safety reviews are abundantly available in Amazon. One of the stories you can find is the story shared by a mother with her then 2-year old child. Their car flipped over and then slid across the road. In the end, their car landed upside down, but the child remained strapped on her seat. Although the child’s shoulders reddened due to the position, her life was miraculously saved.

 

Evenflo Tribute LX Convertible Car Seat, Saturn
By
Price: $83.99
(As of: 2021/10/07 3:56 am - Details
×
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on https://www.amazon.com/ at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
)
3 new from $83.990 used
(* = affiliate link / image source: Amazon partner program)

 

The Seat


 

Cosco Scenera Next Evenflo Tribute LX
Is The Material Breathable? Considerably Yes
Seat Weight: 7.65 pounds 9.1 pounds
Machine Washable Cover? Yes
Roomy? Yes
No-Rethread Harness? No
Comes With An Infant Body Support? No
Easy To Remove Cover? Yes
Expiration 8 Years 6 Years
Comes With A Cup Holder? Yes, 1
Shoulder Harness Has Pads? Sold Separately No
# Of Crotch Strap Positions: 3 2

 

  • Breathable Material

Cosco Scenera Next is considerably breathable since its padding is not too thick. On the other hand, Evenflo Tribute LX might also not be thickly padded, but its cover is said to be made of polyester and is breathable to help keep kids feeling comfortable.

  • Seat Weight

Scenera Next will likely be more portable to carry around for air traveling parents since it is lighter than the Tribute LX.

  • Harness System

No-rethread harness is not among the features offered by these 2 child restraints, but the Scenera Next offers a better option. It has more harness slot positions and it also offers a “newborn routing.”

  • Life Span

Scenera Next has a longer lifespan than Tribute LX. This means it can be used for a longer period of time and can be handed down to more children in the family. Suppose each seat can be used for up to 2 years by each child (forward-facing harness is outgrown), so the Scenera Next can be used by 4 succeeding children while Tribute LX can only be used by 3 consecutive children in the family.

Check Out The Cosco Scenera Next Colors*

Check Out The Evenflo Tribute LX Colors*

 

Compare The Price


 

Cosco Scenera Next

Evenflo Tribute LX

Check The Latest Price*

Check The Latest Price*

 

Conclusion


 

There is an approximately USD15 price difference between the Cosco Scenera Next and the Evenflo Tribute LX. The Scenera Next is cheaper.

Cosco Scenera Next, in my opinion, is the better car seat. Not only does it have a much lower price point in many of the sales pages I have seen, but its features speak well for themselves. 

  • It has a higher rear-facing height limit.
  • It has a higher forward-facing height limit.
  • It is a truly slim car seat that can readily fit in 3-across setups in mid to large sized vehicles.
  • It has been tried and tested to fit on many airlines.
  • It is lighter.
  • It has longer lifespan.
  • It has more harness slots and crotch strap positions.

Of course, this doesn’t make the Evenflo Tribute LX a bad secondary/travel car seat.

 

Do You Need More Help To Decide Between

The Cosco Scenera Next And Evenflo Tribute LX?

See My Cosco Scenera Next Review

Read My Evenflo Tribute LX Review

What do you think? 

I’d love to know your thoughts in the comments section below!

 

Cheers!

sign

 

 

 

*affiliate links

The Cosco Scenera Next And

TAGS: 
I'd love to know your thoughts in the comments section below!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}
error: Content is protected !!